Bumper vs CheckThatVin (2025): Which Vehicle History Report is Best?

Bumper vs CheckThatVin (2025): Which Vehicle History Report Should You Choose?

Bumper.com and CheckThatVin are two popular vehicle history report services, but they serve different needs. Bumper offers subscription-based access with additional market data, while CheckThatVin focuses on single, straightforward reports. The best choice depends on whether you are a frequent car shopper or need a one-time, comprehensive VIN check.

Buying a used car is one of the biggest financial decisions you'll make. The difference between a reliable ride and a money pit often comes down to one thing: its history. A clean-looking exterior can hide a history of accidents, flood damage, or a rolled-back odometer. That's why a vehicle history report (VHR) isn't just a good idea—it's essential.

Two names you might see online are Bumper and CheckThatVin. They both promise to decode a car's past using its 17-digit Vehicle Identification Number (VIN). But how do they stack up? In this 2025 showdown, we'll break down the features, pricing, and data quality of Bumper vs. CheckThatVin to help you decide which service is right for you.

What is a Vehicle History Report and Why Do You Need One?

Before we compare the services, let's cover the basics. A vehicle history report is a detailed summary of a car's life. By running a VIN check, you can uncover critical information that a seller might not disclose. Key data points include:

Accident History: Details on reported collisions, from minor fender-benders to major accidents.
Title Records: Information on salvage, rebuilt, or flood titles that severely impact a car's value and safety.
Odometer Readings: A history of mileage recordings to spot potential odometer fraud.
Service and Repair History: Records of maintenance performed.
Number of Previous Owners: How many hands the car has passed through.
Open Recalls: Unresolved safety recalls issued by the manufacturer, which you can also check on the NHTSA website.

Did you know? The National Insurance Crime Bureau (NICB) estimates that nearly 1 in 4 vehicles has some form of title fraud or unreported damage. A VIN check is your first line of defense.

A graphic illustrating the key data points found in a vehicle history report such as icons for accidents title status odom

Photo by Shooting Tyre on Unsplash

Bumper.com: The Subscription-Based Investigator

Bumper positions itself as more than just a VIN check service. It's a comprehensive automotive tool that bundles vehicle history reports with market valuation data, vehicle specifications, and more. Their primary model is a monthly subscription.

Bumper Features and Data

Unlimited Reports: The main draw is the ability to run as many reports as you want under one subscription. This is ideal for serious car flippers or buyers comparing many different vehicles.
Marketplace Data: Bumper often includes estimated market values, cost of ownership projections, and listings for similar vehicles for sale.
Window Sticker Data: For many vehicles, they can pull up the original window sticker, showing factory options and original MSRP.
Mobile App: They offer a convenient mobile app for checking VINs on the go.

Bumper Pricing

Bumper's pricing is subscription-based. While they may offer introductory trials for a nominal fee, their standard model requires a recurring monthly payment. As of early 2025, this typically falls in the $20-$25 per month range. This can be cost-effective if you plan to check dozens of cars, but expensive for a single purchase.

CheckThatVin: The Straightforward Single Report

CheckThatVin operates on a more traditional, pay-per-report model. It's designed for the average car buyer who has narrowed their search down to one or two vehicles and needs a detailed history without a recurring commitment.

CheckThatVin Features and Data

NMVTIS Data: Like most reputable services, they pull data from the National Motor Vehicle Title Information System (NMVTIS), a reliable source of title and brand history.
Core History Data: Reports focus on the essentials: title history, junk/salvage records, odometer readings, and accident data from participating sources.
No Frills: The service is direct. You enter a VIN, pay for the report, and get the information you need. There are fewer supplementary features like market valuation.

CheckThatVin Pricing

CheckThatVin's pricing is typically on a per-report basis, often with discounts for purchasing small bundles (e.g., 3 or 5 reports). A single report is usually more expensive than one dollar but cheaper than a monthly subscription from Bumper, making it a solid middle-ground option for the focused buyer.

Don't Risk a Costly Mistake.
An undisclosed accident or a branded title can cost you thousands in repairs and lost value. For just $9.99, Carvia provides a comprehensive vehicle history report with AI-powered summaries to help you understand the data instantly. Get peace of mind before you buy. Check Your VIN Instantly

Head-to-Head Comparison: Bumper vs. CheckThatVin

So, which one is better? It depends entirely on your needs as a buyer.

A side by side comparison image showing a sample Bumper report on the left and a sample CheckThatVin report on the right hig

Photo by Shooting Tyre on Unsplash

Best for Value: It's a Tie (Depending on Use)

Winner for single purchase: A service like CheckThatVin or a Bumper alternative like Carvia is better. Paying a one-time fee is far more economical than a monthly subscription if you're only checking one car.
Winner for frequent buyers: Bumper's subscription is the clear winner if you're a dealer, flipper, or a very thorough shopper who plans to run 5, 10, or 20 reports in a month.

Best for Data & Features: Bumper

Bumper generally offers a richer feature set. The inclusion of market values from sources like Kelley Blue Book, original window sticker data, and projected ownership costs provides a more holistic view of the vehicle. CheckThatVin is more focused on the core historical data, which is the most critical part, but lacks these extras.

Best for Simplicity & Ease of Use: CheckThatVin

CheckThatVin's model is simple: pay, and you get your report. Bumper's subscription model can sometimes involve trial periods that convert to recurring charges, which requires more attention to manage if you only need short-term access.

The Carvia Alternative: AI-Powered Insights for a Smarter Price

While Bumper and CheckThatVin are strong contenders, they represent two ends of the spectrum: a recurring subscription or a basic, single report. Carvia offers a compelling middle ground that leverages technology to provide more value.

For a flat fee of $9.99 per report, Carvia provides:

Comprehensive Data: We source data from NMVTIS and other top-tier public and private databases, covering everything from title brands to accident history.
AI-Powered Explanations: Our reports don't just give you data; they explain what it means. Our AI analyzes the report and provides simple, easy-to-understand summaries of potential issues.
No Subscriptions, No Hassle: You only pay for the reports you need. There are no hidden fees or recurring charges to worry about.

If you want the depth of a premium report without the commitment of a subscription, Carvia is designed for the modern, informed car buyer.

Conclusion: Who Should You Choose?

The choice between Bumper and CheckThatVin comes down to your car-buying strategy.

Choose Bumper if: You are a high-volume buyer, a car enthusiast who loves data, or you're in the early stages of shopping and want to check every potential vehicle you see without worrying about per-report costs.
Choose CheckThatVin if: You have already narrowed your choice to one or two cars and need a quick, no-nonsense history check without signing up for a subscription.
Consider Carvia if: You want a single, affordable report that combines comprehensive data with clear, AI-driven insights to make a confident decision.

No matter which service you choose, never skip the vehicle history report. It's the single most important, cost-effective step you can take to protect yourself from buying a vehicle with a hidden, costly past.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Is Bumper.com legitimate?

Yes, Bumper.com is a legitimate service that provides vehicle history reports and other automotive data. They source information from official government agencies, insurance providers, and salvage yards. However, their primary business model is a recurring monthly subscription, which may not be suitable for all users.

What is the best CheckThatVin alternative?

The best CheckThatVin alternative depends on your needs. For users seeking a single, affordable report with advanced features, Carvia is a strong option due to its $9.99 price point and AI-powered explanations. For users who need unlimited reports, a subscription service like Bumper or CARFAX would be a better alternative.

Are VIN check reports always 100% accurate?

No vehicle history report is guaranteed to be 100% accurate or complete. These services rely on data being reported by DMVs, insurance companies, and repair shops. If an accident was never reported or was repaired out-of-pocket, it may not appear on any report. Always supplement a VIN check with a pre-purchase inspection by a trusted mechanic.

Can I get a vehicle history report for free?

Some dealerships provide free CARFAX or AutoCheck reports for the vehicles on their lots. You can also get limited free information, such as title and recall data, directly from the NMVTIS website or NHTSA. However, for a comprehensive accident and service history, a paid report is typically required.