AutoCheck vs. TitleCheck.us (2025): Which VIN Check is Best?

Q: Is AutoCheck or TitleCheck.us better?

Neither is definitively 'better' as they serve different functions. AutoCheck is a comprehensive vehicle history report, while TitleCheck.us is a basic NMVTIS title verification tool. For a complete picture of a car's past, a comprehensive report like AutoCheck or Carvia is necessary.

AutoCheck provides comprehensive vehicle history reports with a proprietary score, while TitleCheck.us offers basic title data from the federal NMVTIS database. For a modern, affordable alternative that combines comprehensive data with AI-powered explanations, Carvia offers a complete solution for today's car buyer.

Buying a used car is one of the biggest financial decisions you'll make. You've found a car that looks perfect online, the price is right, and the seller seems trustworthy. But what's hiding beneath the shiny paint? A clean title and a detailed vehicle history are non-negotiable. Two names you might encounter are AutoCheck and TitleCheck.us, but they serve very different purposes.

Let's break down the differences between AutoCheck and TitleCheck.us to help you decide which service—or a modern alternative—is the right choice for your next car purchase.

What is an AutoCheck Vehicle History Report?

AutoCheck is a well-established vehicle history report provider owned by the credit bureau Experian. It competes directly with CARFAX and provides a detailed history of a vehicle based on its Vehicle Identification Number (VIN). AutoCheck pulls data from thousands of sources, including DMVs, insurance companies, repair shops, and auctions.

Key Features of AutoCheck:

Comprehensive History: Reports include accident data, odometer readings, title history (including salvage or flood brands), number of owners, and service records.
AutoCheck Score: A proprietary, patented scoring system that predicts the likelihood of a vehicle being in service in five years. It compares the specific vehicle to others of the same make and model.
Buyback Protection: Offers a form of protection if certain title brands (like salvage, flood, or fire) were missed on the report.
Pricing: AutoCheck typically costs around $24.99 for a single report, with packages available for checking multiple vehicles over a 21-day period.

Did you know? According to a 2022 study, over 40% of cars for sale at wholesale auctions have some history of damage. A comprehensive report is your first line of defense.

What is TitleCheck.us?

TitleCheck.us is a different kind of service. It is an approved provider of data from the National Motor Vehicle Title Information System (NMVTIS). NMVTIS is a federal database designed to protect consumers from fraud and unsafe vehicles.

A TitleCheck.us report is essentially a direct pull from this government database. It's designed to be a quick, low-cost way to verify critical title information.

Key Features of TitleCheck.us:

NMVTIS Data: Provides the most current title information, history of title brands (like salvage, junk, or flood), latest odometer reading, and any history of the vehicle being reported as a total loss by an insurance company.
Basic Focus: It is not a full vehicle history report. It generally does not include detailed accident reports, service history, number of owners, or other data points found in AutoCheck.
Low Cost: Reports are significantly cheaper, often costing just a few dollars, making it an accessible first-step check.

A split screen image showing a sample AutoCheck report on the left and a simpler TitleCheck us report on the right highlight

Photo by Stas Bezukh on Unsplash

Head-to-Head Comparison: Data, Cost, and Value

Choosing between these two services depends entirely on what information you need to make a confident decision.

Data Sources & Depth

AutoCheck uses a vast network of private and public sources, including NMVTIS data. This gives you a much richer picture of the car's life, including minor accidents or regular maintenance that wouldn't appear in a government title database.

TitleCheck.us relies solely on NMVTIS. While this data is crucial and highly reliable for title-related issues, it's an incomplete history. You could miss a moderate accident that didn't result in a "total loss" declaration or a spotty maintenance history.

Pricing & Value

AutoCheck's price of ~$25 for one report reflects its comprehensive data. The value is in getting a complete story, which can help you negotiate a better price or avoid a lemon altogether.

TitleCheck.us offers incredible value for its specific purpose: verifying a title. At just a few dollars, it's a no-brainer for a quick check, but it shouldn't be your only source of information before a purchase.

The Verdict: You Need More Than Just a Title Check

A clean title is essential, but it's only the first chapter of a car's story. A vehicle could have been in multiple accidents, poorly maintained, or used as a rental car, and still possess a "clean" title. Relying only on a basic NMVTIS report from a service like TitleCheck.us leaves you exposed to significant mechanical and financial risks.

Don't Gamble on an Incomplete History
For just $9.99, Carvia provides a comprehensive vehicle history report that includes title data, accident records, service history, and more. Our AI-powered summaries make it easy to understand the risks, so you can buy with total confidence. Get your Carvia report now

The Modern Alternative: Why Carvia is the Smarter Choice in 2025

While AutoCheck provides good data and TitleCheck.us offers a basic, affordable verification, the modern car buyer needs a solution that blends comprehensive data, clarity, and affordability. That's where Carvia comes in.

Carvia was built for today's market, offering a robust vehicle history report that rivals the legacy brands without the high price tag.

Photo by Stas Bezukh on Unsplash

Comprehensive Data for Less: For only $9.99, Carvia pulls data from NMVTIS, insurance auctions, salvage yards, repair shops, and more. You get the full picture without paying a premium.
AI-Powered Explanations: A list of dates and events can be confusing. Carvia uses AI to analyze the report and provide simple, actionable summaries. It tells you what the data *means* for you as a buyer.
Instant and Easy to Use: Get your report in seconds on any device. No confusing packages or subscriptions—just the report you need, when you need it. Check out our guide on how to read a vehicle history report for more tips.

For less than half the price of a single AutoCheck report, Carvia delivers the critical title data from NMVTIS *plus* the detailed history you need to make an informed decision. It's the best of both worlds.

FAQ: AutoCheck vs. TitleCheck.us

Is AutoCheck or TitleCheck.us better?

Neither is definitively "better" as they serve different functions. AutoCheck is a comprehensive vehicle history report, while TitleCheck.us is a basic NMVTIS title verification tool. For a complete picture of a car's past, a comprehensive report like AutoCheck or Carvia is necessary.

Is a TitleCheck.us report enough to buy a car?

No, a TitleCheck.us report is not sufficient on its own. While it's excellent for flagging major title issues like a salvage or flood brand, it will not show you accident history, service records, or other crucial information that impacts a vehicle's value and reliability.

What is the most reliable vehicle history report?

The most reliable reports pull data from a wide range of sources, including NMVTIS, DMVs, insurance carriers, and service centers. Services like Carvia, AutoCheck, and CARFAX are considered reliable because they aggregate data from these multiple sources to create a complete history.

Can I get a free VIN check?

You can get very basic information for free from sources like the NHTSA for recall information. However, a truly free, comprehensive vehicle history report showing accidents and title history is not available. Low-cost options like Carvia provide the best value for a complete report.