AutoCheck vs EpicVIN (2025): Which VIN Check is Best?

AutoCheck vs. EpicVIN (2025): Which Vehicle History Report Should You Choose?

Q: What is the most reliable vehicle history report?

There is no single 'most reliable' report, as different services have access to slightly different data sources. The most reliable strategy is to use a report from an NMVTIS-approved provider as your baseline, as this data comes directly from state DMVs and insurance carriers. For complete peace of mind, some experts recommend running reports from two different services.

This guide compares AutoCheck and EpicVIN, two popular vehicle history report services. AutoCheck, powered by Experian, offers a proprietary score, while EpicVIN is an affordable, NMVTIS-approved provider. Your choice depends on whether you prioritize a detailed scoring system or budget-friendly, essential data for your used car purchase.

Buying a used car is a minefield of potential problems. You've found a car that looks perfect online, the price is right, and the seller seems trustworthy. But what's hiding beneath that shiny paint? A vehicle history report (VHR) is your single most important tool for uncovering a car's past, from accidents and title issues to odometer fraud.

Two major players you'll encounter are AutoCheck and EpicVIN. Both promise to give you the inside scoop on a vehicle's history using its unique 17-digit Vehicle Identification Number (VIN). But how do they stack up? Let's break down the AutoCheck vs. EpicVIN debate to help you make the smartest choice.

Photo by Axel Antas-Bergkvist on Unsplash

What is a Vehicle History Report and Why Do You Need One?

Before we compare services, let's cover the basics. A VIN check pulls data from a massive network of sources to create a timeline of a vehicle's life. This includes:

Accident History: Reported accidents, severity of damage.
Title Information: Checks for salvage, rebuilt, flood, or lemon titles.
Odometer Readings: Helps identify potential odometer rollback fraud.
Service and Repair Records: Some reports include maintenance history.
Number of Previous Owners: See how many times the car has changed hands.
Lien and Repossession History: Ensures the seller has the legal right to sell the car.

According to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), odometer fraud costs American car buyers over $1 billion annually. A simple VIN check is your first line of defense.

Deep Dive: AutoCheck Vehicle History Reports

AutoCheck is owned by the credit bureau Experian, which gives it access to a vast and unique dataset. It's a long-standing, trusted name in the industry, often used by dealerships.

AutoCheck's Strengths

The AutoCheck Score: This is AutoCheck's signature feature. It provides a simple, at-a-glance score (like a credit score for a car) that compares the vehicle to others of a similar make and model. This can be helpful for quickly assessing a car's relative value and risk.
Experian Data: Leveraging Experian's data network can sometimes uncover information other reports might miss, especially regarding auto finance and lien data.
Buyback Protection: AutoCheck often includes a buyback guarantee if they fail to report a significant title issue (like a salvage brand).

AutoCheck's Weaknesses

Pricing: A single AutoCheck report is typically more expensive than competitors like EpicVIN. Their pricing model often pushes users towards multi-report packages, which you may not need.
Data Gaps: While strong, no single source has all the data. Some users report that AutoCheck can occasionally miss accident data that other services catch.

Deep Dive: EpicVIN Vehicle History Reports

EpicVIN is a newer player but has quickly gained traction by positioning itself as an affordable and reliable AutoCheck alternative. Its key selling point is that it's an officially approved data provider for the National Motor Vehicle Title Information System (NMVTIS).

EpicVIN's Strengths

NMVTIS-Approved: This is a huge trust signal. NMVTIS is a national database run by the U.S. Department of Justice, designed to protect consumers from fraud and unsafe vehicles.
Affordability: EpicVIN reports are generally cheaper than AutoCheck, making them a great option for buyers comparing multiple vehicles on a budget.
Core Data Coverage: It provides all the essential information you need to make an informed decision, including title history, junk/salvage records, odometer readings, and historical data.

EpicVIN's Weaknesses

Fewer "Premium" Features: EpicVIN focuses on the core data. You won't find a proprietary scoring system like the AutoCheck Score.
Less Brand Recognition: While reliable, it doesn't have the same level of brand recognition as AutoCheck or CARFAX, which might matter to some buyers or sellers.

Failing to run a comprehensive VIN check is one of the biggest mistakes a used car buyer can make. Hidden problems like a branded title or unreported accident can cost you thousands in repairs and tank your car's resale value. Don't get stuck with a lemon.

Don't Risk a Bad Buy. Get the Full Story.
For just $9.99, Carvia gives you a complete vehicle history report with AI-powered explanations that make complex data easy to understand. Protect your investment with trusted data from official sources. Check your VIN instantly

AutoCheck vs. EpicVIN: A Head-to-Head Comparison

A person standing next to a used car looking at a vehicle history report on their smartphone with a concerned expression

Photo by Axel Antas-Bergkvist on Unsplash

1. Data Sources and Accuracy

AutoCheck pulls from Experian's exclusive database, auctions, repair shops, and government agencies. Its strength is in its breadth of private data sources.

EpicVIN leans heavily on its status as an approved NMVTIS data provider, ensuring it has access to critical state DMV and insurance data on titles and salvage records. This is its core strength.

Winner: Tie. They pull from different, but equally important, data pools. For maximum protection, serious buyers sometimes run reports from two different providers.

2. Report Content and Features

Both reports cover the essentials: title problems, odometer history, accident data, and owner history. The key difference is the AutoCheck Score. If you value a single, easy-to-understand number to guide your decision, AutoCheck has the edge. If you prefer to analyze the raw data yourself, EpicVIN provides everything you need without the extra layer of interpretation.

Winner: AutoCheck, but only if you find its proprietary score valuable.

3. Pricing and Value

This is where the difference is clearest. A single report from EpicVIN is almost always cheaper than a single report from AutoCheck.

AutoCheck Pricing: Typically around $25 for one report.
EpicVIN Pricing: Often available for under $15 for one report.

For a buyer looking at three or four different cars, the cost savings with an EpicVIN alternative can add up quickly.

Winner: EpicVIN for budget-conscious shoppers.

The Verdict: Which VIN Check Service is Right for You?

So, should you choose AutoCheck or EpicVIN? The answer depends on your needs.

Choose AutoCheck if:

You are a dealer or a very serious buyer who values the simplicity of the AutoCheck Score.
You want the potential benefit of Experian's financial and lien data.
Price is not your primary concern.

Choose EpicVIN if:

You are a budget-conscious buyer comparing several vehicles.
You want a reliable, NMVTIS-approved report with all the essential data.
You are comfortable interpreting the data without a proprietary score.

Ultimately, both are vast improvements over buying a car with no history check at all. They serve a critical purpose in the used car buying process, alongside a pre-purchase inspection and a thorough test drive.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Is EpicVIN as good as AutoCheck?

EpicVIN is a strong competitor and a great value, especially because it's an approved NMVTIS data provider. It provides the essential title and accident history you need. AutoCheck's main advantage is its proprietary AutoCheck Score and data from its parent company, Experian, which may appeal to some users.

What is the most reliable vehicle history report?

There is no single "most reliable" report, as different services have access to slightly different data sources. The most reliable strategy is to use a report from an NMVTIS-approved provider as your baseline, as this data comes directly from state DMVs and insurance carriers. For complete peace of mind, some experts recommend running reports from two different services.

Can a VIN check tell me everything about a car?

No, a VIN check is a powerful tool but has limitations. It can only report what has been officially documented. Minor accidents that were never reported to insurance or police, or maintenance done by private individuals, will not appear. Always combine a vehicle history report with a physical inspection by a trusted mechanic.